I had Marty’s pizza back when I was a child living on Pewaukee lake and I’m so happy that some 40 years later I’ve moved back to the area and it’s still as delicious as I remember. The cheesy garlic bread is great as well. Our server was very friendly and helpful. I live in Milwaukee now but drove to Delafield because the hours at the Brookfield location aren’t convenient for my schedule
Ok.. stopped for lunch. Ordered 2 fishfrys since the waitress said it was breaded cod and to pizzas to go when we were ready to leave as take and bake. So, the choice was ff's or potato pancakes. Food came potato pancakes were Tator tots, and the fish was equal to or less grocery store bought breaded fish. Service was slow and hit and miss, had to ask for soda refills. When we were leaving wife commented on the fish to waitress and comment was "WELL WE ARE A ITALIAN RESTURANT". Went to pay, repeat of waitress comment, very rude Mgr!!!
My husband and I have been visiting Marty's Pizza for almost two decades. We enjoy their pizza, breadsticks, and garlic bread. Their pizza has a nice crispy cracker crust and the perfect ratio of toppings. Their pizzas are also available in a multitude of sizes which makes them great for large and small groups. Very happy with our visits to Marty's Pizza and will continue to visit!
For the past 7 years, we have been ordering take out pizza from Marty's pizza. Every time you order, it's a crap shoot. You never know if it will be good or bad. Last Friday, I decided to try them again. Big mistake !!!!! The pizza was one of the worst ones yet. Have had enough. Now, I am on the hunt for another pizza shop.